Utica First Insurance Company

Advantages of Working at Utica First

  • Since the success of the company ultimately depends on the combined efforts of our employees, we are vitally interested in their personal and professional growth. As they continue to develop and advance, the Company will become a stronger organization that is better equipped to meet the challenges of tomorrow. Every employee is important to our success.
  • The Company provides reimbursement to regular employees for tuition, books, and fees associated with approved professional certifications and designations and other specified expenses incurred while pursuing professional self development programs.
  • We have a family-like atmosphere.
  • We will support your individual goals and professional development.

Our Benefits Plan

  • 401K plan
  • Health care insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Flexible Spending Accounts
  • Paid Vacation
  • Paid Personal Time
  • Paid Sick Time
  • Generous Paid Holidays
  • Life Insurance and AD&D
  • Long-term Disability
  • Workers' Compensation Insurance
  • Employee Assistance Program
02/13/2026  
Utica First Insurance Company has been serving the insurance needs of families and businesses for over 100 years. We have a dedicated “team” of employees and offer continuing opportunity for personal career growth. Utica First Insurance Company is currently seeking an Underwriting Consultant for our Oriskany, NY location.   Reports To: Vice Preside of Underwriting   Schedule: Monday-Friday, 8:00am to 4:00pm (OT as necessary) Requirements · Provide expert-level file consultation, including coverage interpretation and rating guidance. · Primary technical authority on risks. · Identify and recommend solutions for underwriting exceptions, borderline risks, or referrals. · Assist in evaluating new products, endorsements, and coverage forms. · Develop, update, and maintain underwriting guidelines, appetite guides, and line-of-business playbooks. · Partner with leadership to ensure underwriting practices align with reinsurance treaties,...
Utica First Insurance Company Oriskany, NY, USA
02/04/2026  
   Job Summary : The Claims Casualty Manager oversees a team of claims adjusters and manages complex claims for a variety of policies, including general liability, homeowners, and business owners’ policies. This role is responsible for managing the claims process from start to finish, ensuring policy interpretation and coverage analysis, setting claim reserves, and working to achieve timely and cost-effective resolutions. They also conduct data analysis to identify trends, provide insights to other departments, and ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. Reports to : Vice President of Claims Duties and Responsibilities Include (but not limited to) : · Manage the entire claims process, from initial notification to final resolution, while ensuring the team follows best practices. · Provide direction and technical expertise to claims adjusters, especially for complex or litigated cases. · Analyze and interpret insurance policies to determine...
Utica First Insurance Company Oriskany, NY, USA
01/29/2026  
   Utica First Insurance Company has been serving the insurance needs of families and businesses for over 100 years. We have a dedicated “team” of employees and offer continuing opportunity for personal career growth. Utica First Insurance Company is currently seeking a Senior Infrastructure Analyst for our Oriskany, NY location.   Reports To Director of Information Technology Schedule:  Monday-Friday, 8:00am to 4:00pm Requirements    Responsibilities Include but are not limited to: · Designs, implements and supports enterprise infrastructure solutions · Leads troubleshooting of complex infrastructure issues · Serves as technical lead on infrastructure and integration projects · Develops and enforces standards, documentation and best practices · Provides mentorship and training to infrastructure analysts and support staff · Evaluates emerging technologies and recommends improvements to infrastructure strategy · Provide support and...
Utica First Insurance Company Oriskany, NY, USA
01/07/2026  
Utica First Insurance Company has been serving the insurance needs of families and businesses for over 100 years. We have a dedicated “team” of employees and offer continuing opportunity for personal career growth. Utica First Insurance Company is currently seeking a Marketing Representative for our Pennsylvania territory. This candidate must reside in the state of Pennsylvania. The Marketing Representative primary function is to maintain and grow customers in their territory. Representatives should be able to assess agents’ needs and risks to recommend suitable coverage, manage agents accounts, and manage policy updates and renewals. This individual should be able to identify and educate potential agents on policy options and build relationships to meet company goals.  Reports To Vice President of Marketing Requirements    Duties/Responsibilities Visit the assigned agents on a regular basis for the following purposes: ·...
Utica First Insurance Company USA